- Sgt.G 2
- Sgt.Muffin 11
- ShaDiE 2
- Shadow 'tricky' dragon 4
- Shadow Dance (or Shadow Dancer) 5
- Shadow Dancer 6
- Shadow Z6 3
- Shadow-Zero 4
- Shadow97 3
- ShadowBow 10
- Shadowfire 2
- Shadrak (a.k.a. Ex-terminator) 3
- Shahid Ali 25
- Shakka 7
- Shamus Young 10
- Shane 4
- Shane 'PænKillër' Tranuse 3
- Shane (Gullonefox) bromham 9
- Shane Caudle 135
- Shane Caudle - Converted to 4
- Shane Caudle - LE: Mike "Hellscrag" Wilberforce 5
- Shane Caudle - MH 4
- Shane Caudle [AS > MH zeal] 2
- Shane Caudle made to 2
- Shane Caudle/ mod - dinwitty 2
- Shane Lingo 2
- Shane Phillips 2
- Shane Transue 5
- Sharko 3
- Shaun "MMAN UGITU" Friend 7
- Shaun Claudle 4
- Shaun Goeppinger aka Iniquitous 7
- Shaun Goeppinger aka ini 3
- Shawn "AmranX" Davison 5
- Shawn "Buddha337" Johnson 5
- Shawn "Bulish" Norwood 13
- Shawn "DarkMantle" Rudolph 5
- Shawn "Heimdall" Cantu 9
- Shawn "NeoPendragon" Lisk 3
- Shawn "URDead" Kyle 2
- Shawn (Nomad 2
- Shawn **Monarch** Yarbrough 5
- Shawn Bosel 3
- Shawn Szczepanski 2
- Shawn"BuLish"Norwood 6
- Shawn"Wicked"Norwood 5
- Shdwrnnr 2
- Sheoth 2
- Shexpeare 4
- Shimmer 11
- Shinigami 10
- Shinji 3
- Shinn 2
- Shinox 40
- Shiva 2
- Shivaxi 3
- ShobE & Zeh 2
- Shock 2
- Shock Systems 22
- Shon "Maric" Shaffer 2
- Shoto 2
- Shred 5
- ShredPrince 2
- Shuhou "XepptizZ" Tse 2
- Shuriken 3
- Shved 6
- Si "Kain" Cass 11
- Si 'Daywalker' Jones 2
- SiLeNt_NiGhT 6
- SiR CharLZ 5